Who We Are

Miss Cristy’s Bakery in Delaware, OH is dedicated to providing our customers with fresh, home-baked goods the way they were intended to be enjoyed – packed with flavor and 100% preservative-free. We use quality ingredients to produce quality products. Order today to discover our quality difference for yourself!

Home-Baked Pies

Our pies are available in two sizes:

  • 6-inch pies (individual serving) – perfect for those that do not like to share - $6.00 each
  • 9-inch pies (family size pies) – made for sharing with family and friends - $13.00 each.


Apple Buttermilk Pie – spiced apples combined with creamy buttermilk custard and topped with a buttery streusel…sure to be a family favorite!

Blackberry Pie – filled with whole blackberries and topped with a beautiful lattice crust. It as tasty as it is pretty.
Buckeye Pie – peanut butter and chocolate…an Ohio favorite! This is like eating a peanut butter cookie with chocolate chips in a pie crust.
Cherry Pie – a delicious combination of sweet and tart cherries nestled under a lattice top crust…a beautiful centerpiece!
Chocolate Chip Pie – can’t decide between cookies and pie? Why not have both…like eating a cookie in a pie crust!
Creamy Blueberry Pie – loaded with whole blueberries and drizzled with a creamy custard. A true blueberry lover’s delight!
Lemon Chess Pie – a southern favorite! The subtle taste of lemon in a creamy custard pie – like eating springtime any time of year!

Mixed Berry Pie – a combination of sweet berries (strawberries, raspberries, blueberries, and blackberries) happily combine for an explosion of berry goodness.

Peach Pie – big chunks of peaches and a magical blend of seasoning and you’ll wonder how you ever lived without this seasonal favorite…yum!

Pumpkin Pie – for the pumpkin connoisseur – an autumn tradition!

Pumpkin Apple Pie – can’t decide between apple pie and pumpkin pie? Why not have both? This one truly has been described as eating both pies at the same time!

Rhubarb Pie – a seasonal favorite. Big chunks of rhubarb in a double crust pie!

Sweet Potato Pie – for the sweet potato lover in you. Packed with fresh sweet potatoes, this is a perfect start to the holiday season.

Strawberry Rhubarb Pie – another seasonal favorite. Fresh rhubarb and fresh strawberries combine to welcome the start of the summer season!


Tiny bite-sized versions of some of our favorite pies. Get a package of 12 for only $9.00!

  • Buckeye
  • Chocolate Chip

  • Lemon Chess
  • Pecan

Fried Pies

Fruit filling wrapped around pie crust and flash fried. These tasty morsels have the look of an empanada with the consistency of a donut. Get a package of 8 for only $7.00!


  • Apple
  • Blueberry
  • Mixed Berry

  • Strawberry Banana
  • Chocolate Covered Banana